Changes to Peter Pan the Musical

*This appeared as an op-ed in the Sunday, November 30 edition of the Star Tribune.

 By Peter C. Brosius, Artistic Director

Peter Pan by J.M. Barrie is a story that continues to inspire and engage audiences one hundred years after its publication. For this reason, its limited and outdated representations of Native Americans may seem forgivable, even benign.

It is not. It is racist.

To say otherwise is to deny that stories have power. When we tell stories, we are making the world. Peter Pan is a powerful, enduring story deeply embedded in our mainstream cultural consciousness. So what is our responsibility as a theatre company when we produce classic stories, parts of which are offensive?

When we decided to program Peter Pan the Musical, we knew that we could not portray Tiger Lily and the “Indians” of Neverland as Barrie, Disney or Broadway had. Though Barrie may have considered his portrayal of Native Americans to be positive, he lived in a time dominated by British colonialist ideals that were rife with racial stereotypes. Many offensive elements exist in the original, including the use of words like “redskin,” as well as dialogue spoken in broken English. The “Indians” in Peter Pan not only bear no resemblance to Native people, they also exist alongside imagined creatures such as mermaids and fairies, which in turn casts them as fictitious characters. While this does not invalidate the story’s core beauty and power, it does marginalize and disrespect Native Americans, something that Children’s Theatre Company refuses to perpetuate.

So why put Peter Pan on our stage at all? The fact is that despite its insensitive material, Peter Pan does contain positive messages worth sharing with today’s audiences. It beautifully captures the spirit of flight, adventure, imagination and what it means to grow up – something we believe is reason enough to continue to tell this story. Any artistic process is an act of interpretation and to some extent a reimagining of the original material. In telling Peter Pan on our stage for today’s audiences, our responsibility lies in telling it in the most respectful way possible while maintaining the beauty that has enchanted us for a century.

In order to do this, we connected with local and national Native artists and educators, as well as Native members of CTC staff and board to gather a multiplicity of viewpoints and responses to our proposed artistic solutions. This significant and generous input within a series of community conversations revealed the depth of harmful and problematic elements in the original material. We ultimately concluded that the success of our version depended on eliminating hurtful stereotypes and not depicting Native Americans alongside imagined creatures.

In our version of Peter Pan, we reimagine Tiger Lily as the leader of a group of powerful young women, a counterpart to the Lost Boys. Tiger Lily will keep her name, which has never had a connection to authentic Native American culture. One of the core ideas of Peter Pan is that children have the power to enact real change, independent of adult intervention. Our version expresses that theme more clearly, pairing the group of young women with the Lost Boys to defeat Captain Hook and his pirates.

These revisions had to be approved by the license holder, Music Theatre International (MTI) in order for us to incorporate them into our production. We knew we would not produce Peter Pan at CTC unless our proposal was approved. We were thrilled and heartened when MTI gave us permission to make the changes. We are hopeful that this version could be a thoughtful and respectful solution for those producing Peter Pan in the future.

We know classic texts can pose challenges. It is our job to look at every story we program and bring out the essential messages for our audiences in a way that honors and welcomes all families. When we make theatre, we explore how the world should be and how it should function. A play can bring together a group of strangers – from different backgrounds and with different perspectives – to share in something beautiful, something larger than any individual. That is the power of theatre. That is the power of story.

News Archive

Privacy Policy

Thank you for reviewing the privacy policy and disclaimer.

Children’s Theatre Company (“CTC”) is committed to providing a safe online experience. We collect no personally identifying information, unless you choose to provide us with that information. This statement of Privacy applies to the CTC website and governs data collection and usage. By using the CTC website, you consent to the data practices described in this statement.

If you visit our site to browse, read, watch videos or download, we automatically collect and store only the following information about you:
  • The IP address from which you access our Web site (an IP address serves two principal functions: host or network interface identification and location addressing.)
  • The type of browser and operating system used to access our site
  • The date and time you access our site
  • The pages you visit
  • and The Internet address of the Web site from which you accessed our site

This information is used to improve the functionality of the website—to learn about the number of visitors to our site and the types of technology our visitors use. We do not track or record information about individuals and their visits. We may compile and report aggregate statistics about our users — numbers, traffic patterns, and related site information — but these statistics will include no personally identifying information. CTC is not responsible for privacy statements or other content on websites outside of CTC, including those linked from CTC’s website.


If you identify yourself by submitting mailing list, donor or ticket request forms contained in the site, we use that information only to respond to your message and to help us provide you with the material you have requested or to send you a written acknowledgment of your donation as required by law, or to verify and/or mail purchases and/or to process your ticket order.

You have the option to contact us by phone or by email ([email protected]) to request that we remove your name from our mailing and/or calling and/or trade list. If you opt to be taken off our mailing list, you will receive no mail from us, including publications or special notices. If you opt to be removed from our calling list, you will receive no calls from us except when a performance is canceled. We will not sell, trade or share a donor’s personal information with anyone else, nor send donor mailings on behalf of other organizations. If you are not a donor and you opt to be removed from our trade list, we will not provide your name to other arts organizations that might be making special offers or anyone else.


CTC’s website uses "cookies" to help you personalize your online experience. A cookie is a text file that is placed on your hard disk by a web page server. Cookies cannot be used to run programs or deliver viruses to your computer. Cookies are uniquely assigned to you, and can only be read by a web server in the domain that issued the cookie to you.

The purpose of a cookie is to tell the web server that you have returned to a specific page. We and our advertising partners, including advertising networks, use information gathered through cookies and other similar technologies, as well as other information we or they may have, to help tailor the ads you see on our sites and to help make decisions about the ads you see on other sites. To opt-out of targeted adversity from many ad networks visit:

You have the ability to accept or decline cookies. Most web browsers automatically accept cookies. Please be aware that some web pages may not work correctly if cookies are disabled. More information is available here:


All credit card transactions including ticket purchases and donations is processed on a secure server. Credit card information is protected by encryption technology, such as the Secure Socket Layer (SSL) protocol. This helps to assure information is protected from unauthorized access.


CTC may occasionally update our Statement of Privacy to reflect customer feedback or changing technologies. CTC encourages you to review this statement periodically.


CTC welcomes comments and questions about or Statement of Privacy. If you believe CTC has not adheared to this statement, please contact us at [email protected].


Under no circumstances shall CTC, its employees or contractors be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, punitive or consequential damages that may result in any way from your use or inability to use the information provided on this or any other web site supported or maintained by CTC or from your reliance on or use of information, services or merchandise provided on or through the web site or that result from mistakes, errors, omissions, interruptions, defects, deletion of files, delays in operation or transmission or any failure of performance. If you are dissatisfied with the information provided on this web site, or with any of the practices of the CTC in the operation of this web site, your sole and exclusive remedy is to discontinue using the web site.